Social Safeguards: Avoiding the Unintended Impacts of Development
Large-scale development projects oftentimes end up creating negative impacts that affect vulnerable populations with particular intensity. Projects likely to displace families from their homes, degrade the living conditions of indigenous peoples or intensify social conflicts at local levels are not uncommon. Social safeguards are intended to prevent these and other unintended impacts, and when the impacts cannot be averted, to develop appropriate measures to mitigate them. However, the practical implementation of social safeguards is plagued with a series of structural problems. The collection of stories from the field presented in this book illustrates the principles and application of social safeguards in the context of projects funded by multilateral banks, identifying key challenges in their implementation and exploring paths to overcome those limitations.
This is a highly recommended book for any person looking to understand how multilateral banks currently manage the potentially negative social impacts of their investment projects.
Specific areas where readers will also develop greater knowledge and awareness include:
- Reasons why social safeguards exist and their overarching goals - How social safeguard policies are regularly implemented in practice - The top ten limitations to the preparation of social impact assessments - Operational challenges of involuntary resettlement and economic displacement - Current procedures to prevent negative impacts on indigenous peoples - Existing measures to prevent gender risks and promote greater gender equity - How to promote authentic participatory processes in consultation mechanisms - How to increase the social sustainability standards of economic development
“Social Safeguards: Avoiding the Unintended Impacts of Development,” by Rodolfo Tello. Available in hardcover, paperback and electronic editions, April 1, 2015. 120 pages.
You can order this book at these and other stores:
"An important, engaging, and thoroughly original book ... Social Safeguards demands that we pay attention to the negative impacts of development projects, that we listen to those being harmed, and that we find ways to ensure that the benefits of development are shared equally."--David Vine, author of Island of Shame
"Could you imagine what may happen to you and your family if you were forced to leave your home because of a development project? This is a recommended reading about the challenges, pitfalls and lessons from the evolving relationship between big infrastructure projects and local communities".--Lidia Reboucas, Sr. Social Consultant, ERM Brazil
“A book that should be read by all of us in the development industry.It illustrates in simple, highly accessible language why we have social safeguards … Tello humanizes those policies by illustrating the purpose of social safeguards: to strengthen our capacity to insure that the least among us have the opportunity to participate in the development process”--William Partridge, consultant in international development and former lead anthropologist at the World Bank
"A book with gripping personal stories of indigenous people facing hardship from development projects and how development workers can mitigate that hardship by talking and listening to people's concerns." --Brett Williams, Professor, American University
A sample fragment is presented next:
A Few Yards Away
The old woman showed us an eviction notice she had received a few weeks before. She was to remove her belongings and disassemble the hut she had built on the side of the road over twenty years ago. She had only two more weeks left before the government started enforcing that notice. Her precarious place of residence was the only home she could afford because it was free. "What should I do?" she asked us. "We have nowhere to go." A tone of desperation was evident in her voice. Her grandchildren had stopped playing in the yard and were watching us apprehensively; they knew trouble was coming and were waiting to see if there was any ray of hope.
Helen, a member of the team visiting this rural area of Nicaragua, tried to divert the children's attention away from the problem. She asked them about their dolls and what games they were playing, if they attended school, how far it was, how they got there. Her efforts seemed to help the kids feel better; they welcomed the distraction. In the meantime, we continued talking to the old lady, trying to find out more about her situation, how this upcoming move would affect her and her family, and trying to figure out the available alternatives to prevent this family from becoming homeless.
The family’s settling in next to an unpaved segment of a road with little traffic had not been an issue until now, when the construction of a wider paved road was imminent. Had the old woman originally settled a few yards farther away from the centerline of the road, she would probably not be in trouble today. Laws usually recognize possession rights of public lands occupied by people after a number of years. However, moving her house a few yards back is no longer an option because that land is now owned by someone else, and if she invaded private property, she would most likely end up being summarily expelled, mistreated, and worse.
Left on her own, the old woman would probably have to disassemble her hut and carry it to some other segment of the road where no construction was anticipated. She would hire someone to help her with the move if she only had the money to afford it, which she does not. She does not know where she could go, either. Her frail condition has prevented her from leaving the hut much lately. She would need time and resources to scout for a new place and repeat this informal settling-in process somewhere else, but she has neither.
She would also have to figure out a way to get access to water, finding a place near a stream, since building a well requires a lot of heavy work and she does not have that kind of strength anymore. She would also need to be close to a road so that her grandchildren can travel to a school within a reasonable distance. At her age, she also needs access to a health center. She needs the free painkillers it provides to deal with the aches associated with the aging process, and her grandchildren also get sick on a frequent basis.
She would have to say goodbye to her neighbors as well. Once she moves, she will not be able to come back for regular visits. All the little favors that sometimes made a big difference would stop, such as that time when her grandniece had a stomachache in the middle of the night and a neighbor gave them medicine to alleviate the pain, or when she borrowed money for urgent transportation to the nearby town when she did not have any, or when their friends provided her with information that helped her daughter get a job in the city, or when she received encouraging advice about not giving in to despair in times of crisis, or when they got together for social events that reinforced their sense of belonging. All the benefits of that social network would be soon gone.
This move would also cost lots of money, more than she regularly spends to sustain herself and her family on a monthly basis. She thinks about it over and over but cannot see a viable option. In the meantime, the clock is ticking. She wants to get drunk and forget about it, but then she thinks about her grandchildren and that helps her keep sober. The visiting team has brought up the issue once again, but she still does not know what to do. She looks at us and asks again, "Is there anything you can do?"
We offer words of encouragement but cannot make any promises at that particular moment. As social practitioners representing an international organization funding the road improvement project, our findings and recommendations will first need to be discussed with the officials of the executing agency in charge of implementing the project, and we will need to agree on a set of actions to be performed within a sensible time frame to mitigate the negative impacts of the project, particularly those affecting vulnerable people. We anticipate that these discussions may not go easy, since the level of effort and cost of restoring the living conditions of the affected population to the acceptable standards used by international organizations could be significant. It starts by recognizing possession rights and the need to replace the affected infrastructure, offering housing solutions determined in a participatory way. The houses would need to have access to basic services, even in cases when the population did not previously have them. The affected people would need a path for legal ownership of the house, and a support mechanism to help them overcome the disruptions to their lifestyle and social networks created by the transition, in addition to logistic support. They should also be able to reproduce their means of sustenance. The goal is to avoid impoverishment by generating similar or better living conditions for the affected population.
Enabling these conditions has a significant cost, particularly when we multiply it by the total number of families affected by a project. While the situation of each family may be somewhat different, the overall principle is that each of the affected families should be subject to appropriate mitigation measures, commensurate to the type and magnitude of the affectation. However, decision-makers oftentimes show reluctance to approve investments in anything besides the core elements of a project, as part of a tendency to avoid addressing externalities. Fortunately, Helen has lots of experience dealing with high-level government officials on these issues. The field visit allows us to get a better...
You can order this book at these and other stores:
Reader's Favorite Award
"Judo: Seven Steps to Black Belt" won Reader's Favorite silver medal in the 2016 Non-Fiction - Sports category.